Bardstown, Kentucky, has an unusual
story that people love to tell. This story is a ghost story, but it
runs a little deeper than your average ghost story. This is the story
of the moving gravestone in the Federal Hill Cemetery, and it has
been around for at least 150 years.
John Rowan was a famous man in his
hometown, having served seven terms in elected offices, along with
being a state judge and working as a State Senator. Later in life he
would also serve as a chief justice on the Kentucky Court of Appeals
and also serving as the Secretary of State for Kentucky. He was also
the cousin of Stephen Foster, who penned a number of his songs during
the 19<sup>th</sup> century.
Though he was fairly popular in the
state, he experienced more than his fair share of rough times. As a
child he was frequently sick, and doctors told his family that he may
not live past an early age. This prompted the family to move to a
country estate in Kentucky. He began changing his life, and studied
law as a student. He even married a young woman named Ann Lytle.
Lytle's father passed along land to the young couple upon which they
built Federal Hill.
One night while playing a game of cards
at the house, Rowan began arguing with a man by the name of James
Chambers. The two were casual friends, and the argument was a silly
one that quickly grew more heated. After Rowan insulted the man's
wife, he demanded a duel. The duel led outside, and only Rowan
survived.
This could have disturbed a smaller
man, but Rowan persevered. However even he could not persevere the
cholera epidemic that swept Kentucky in 1833. All told the man lost
26 slaves and four members of his immediate family, including his son
John who was Andrew Jackson's Secretary of State. John stopped by the
house to visit his family, contracted cholera, and passed away in the
house.
Rowan himself passed away in 1843, and
told family and close friends that he didn't want a monument or
marker on his grave. The man believed in pride, and felt that his
meager grave didn't deserve such a high honor. He further claimed
that the elaborate house he had built on Federal Hill was a monument
in and of itself.
Rowan was eventually buried in the
Bardstown Cemetery, though his remains were later moved to Federal
Hill Cemetery. Upon his grave family members erected a large obelisk
type monument, with the belief that his life fitted such a memorial.
That was when things began happening.
The moment the monument was complete,
it fell over without warning. Despite spending a good amount of time
trying to decide why the stone fell, no one could find a good reason.
The best excuse they could find was that roots from a nearby tree had
caused too much pressure on the base of the monument.
Not long after, the stone tipped over
again. Each time it was replaced, it would stand in place for a few
weeks or months, but would eventually topple over again. Eventually
local stone workers began refusing to return to the cemetery. Locals
began saying that this was Rowan expressing his displeasure at the
monument. Some even claimed that he had threatened his family prior
to his death at what would happen if his wishes were not followed.
Though it has been 150 years since the
monument was first placed in the cemetery, it still continues to
regularly follow over today. I visited the cemetery once when I was
living in Louisville, Kentucky and I have to say that I didn't
experience anything unusual. The monument is not as grand as some
that I have seen in the past, but it is easy to find. It was standing
when I was there, but maybe the next time I visit, it will have
toppled over again.